91 Points from Wine Enthusiast

We’re excited to share that TWO of our 2025 wines have received 91 points from Christina Pickard at Wine Enthusiast!

Back label of the 2025 Good Earth Riesling2025 Good Earth Riesling: “An exciting first vintage from a new block of sensitively farmed vines from a pair of thoughtful producers on Seneca Lake. This offers lovely tension and complexity via a nose of lemongrass, lime pith and white blossoms underscored with something more mineral and flinty. There’s a hint of sugar on the palate that’s lifted by zippy acidity and fleshy-yet-delicate fruit.”

2025 Petillant Naturel: “A hazy strawberry juice hue, this Finger Lakes pet nat gives red apple cider vibes, with some berry fruit and dried herb aromas thrown in for good measure. It’s bone dry and a little wild, but not funky, and the crisp crunch of acidity keeps it an easy-drinking refreshing drop for a summer picnic or lakeside hang.”

The Pet Nat has also been labeled a “Hidden Gem” by Wine Enthusiast, which we are obviously delighted by!

Both of these wines are currently available to taste and purchase at the Winegarden, and can also be ordered online.